jump to navigation

Curbing homosexuality not a solution for HIV: HC October 2, 2008

Posted by nitinkarani in English, Indian Express, Section 377.

From The Indian Express:


Posted: Sep 30, 2008 at 1809 hrs IST

New Delhi, September 30: The Delhi High Court said that problem of HIV cannot be solved by curbing gay sex and pulled up the Centre for seeking the retention of penal provisions against homosexuality on this ground.”Please show material, research paper or any document even from other country to show that decriminalisation (of gay sex) would lead to spread of HIV,” a bench comprising Chief Justice A P Shah and Justice S Muralidhar observed when the Government contended that homosexuality spreads the disease.

“If your argument is correct then spread of HIV should have stopped in the country as the law has been there for many years. But it is not the case as many people are dying of the dreaded disease, the court said.

The court objected to the contention of Additional Solicitor General P P Malhotra that the Home Ministry’s affidavit, on which the government is relying, does not say any thing on this aspect.

“It’s a strange situation. Your first affidavit (Home Ministry’s) is silent. There is not a single word on what you are saying while other affidavit (Health Ministry’s) is pointing out that the penal provision leads to marginalisation of HIV patients,” the court said.”How would the court decide the matter. Has there been any empirical study done by the government to substantiate its stand,” the court said.

It said that a special law should be made to provide proper care and treatment to HIV patients like other countries.

“Unlike other countries we have not brought any special laws for people suffering from the disease on the pretext that penal provision under Indian Penal Code is sufficient,” it said.

Putting forward the Centre’s view, the Additional Solicitor General said that gay sex is a threat to society and it could not be decriminalised.

“Right to health of few persons cannot supersede Right to health of society. There has to be balance between them and it is for this purpose that Section 377 is there,” Malhotra said.

The court was hearing a PIL filed by gay rights activists seeking courts direction to amend Section 377 of Indian Penal Code by decriminalising gay sex among consenting adults in private.

The IPC at present holds an homosexual act as an offence and the Section provides a punishment of up to life imprisonment for indulging in such acts.

Earlier, gay rights activists had contended that the government, by decriminalising [sic] homosexual acts, is infringing upon their fundamental right to equality by decriminalising [sic] homosexual acts on the ground of morality.

“The Constitution gives fundamental right to equality and it prohibits discrimination on the basis of sex. But the rights of 25 lakh homosexuals in the country are being violated,” they had contended on Thursday

The IPC at present holds homosexual act as an offence and the Section provides a punishment of up to life imprisonment for indulging in such acts.

“Moral argument cannot triumph over the constitutional rights in a democratic society where fundamental rights prohibit any discrimination on the ground of sex,” the activists had said adding that gays in the country don’t have full “moral” citizenship and they are being treated as second class citizens….



1. youngnewtonian - October 3, 2008

Wow very informative. I would like to present MY views on this topic after having read this article. HIV is not being spread because of homosexuality is partly true. Partly because we are not counting the people who keep there relation under the lid. But even if we don’t consider it, then drugs, medical equipment and sex are probably the main causes of HIV. There could be other minor causes but we will only look at these. Sex is a big cause of HIV; to be precise unlawful sex. Now if we only consider heterosexuals here then just think how much HIV is being spread by heterosexuality alone. Decriminalizing the consenting homosexual relationship will cause homosexuality rise. We haven’t seen such a thing before and we are not aware of the consequences. All I want to say is that homosexuality is so far not to blame, but decriminalizing it will be like throwing a log to fire when it comes to HIV.It will increase HIV definitely. It is not discrimination if it is conforming to some other law. For example in America no criminal is allowed to vote. Now is it discrimination? NO. Same is the case here. There is a law which doesn’t allow them to marry. Now this is not discrimination considering the above law.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: